How to get an S Rank in Loveless in Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth
In order to get the Critically Acclaimed trophy in Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth, you must achieve an S rank or higher in the Loveless mini-game. In addition, if you want to earn Johnny’s Treasure Item No. 37-41, you will have to replay the Loveless mini-game at least 3 times with each of your female party members as your date; Tifa, Aerith, and Yuffie. You must score an S rank or higher with all three. Aerith is the default Rosa if Tifa nor Yuffie are either of your dates.
There are three choices within the mini-game that you will have to take in order to advance. These choices only affect the difficulty of each act, where the speed and the amount of input prompts increase. The higher the difficulty the more chances you get to get a higher ranking than an S.
Loveless Act I
During the first act, you will have to choose between clashing against Varvados or Garm. Regardless of whom you choose, the difficulty level will start at 1 star rating.
Loveless Act II
Depending on who you chose to confront in the last act, this time, the remaining enemy (Varvados/Garm) will be pit against your love and give the choice on whom to choose. You must choose your love, so that the difficulty increase to a 2 star rating.